ACELC — CCM’s Hidden Opinions

Coming on the heels of Pastor Noland’s article on What’s Wrong with the CCM, here’s news of a ruling by the CCM that was made without contacting the subject of the ruling, nor doing research to look at their website to find accurate information.


CCM opinion 11-2589 and the ACELC

“The sum of Your Word is truth, and every one of Your righteous rules endures forever.” Psalm 119:160

ACELCOn July 15, 2010, the Association of Confessing Evangelical Lutheran Congregations (ACELC) mailed a “Letter of Fraternal Admonition” to every congregation in the LCMS. At that time the ACELC was not an organized group, but merely a collection of individuals concerned about their church, and a number of matters of doctrine and practice that seemed to be contrary to God’s Word and the Lutheran Confessions.  Many responded favorably to that letter and several months later (March, 2011) the ACELC was officially formed.

On April 4, 2011, a pastor in the LCMS was concerned that someone actually wrote a letter to the congregations of the LCMS pointing out perceived errors of doctrine and practice, and shared that concern with the Synod’s Commission on Constitutional Matters (CCM). In September of 2011, the CCM issued opinion number 11-2589 (reproduced in the 2013 Convention Workbook, p. 288-297).

Please note that at no time did the CCM ever contact anyone in the ACELC to ask any questions or clarify any issues, and because of that made many false assumptions. It is also clear that the CCM did not read the ACELC documents (readily available on our website), which would have cleared up many of their false assumptions. We do not know the name of the Pastor who asked for this opinion and we have not been given a copy of the original letter of concern. We were also not notified that someone had asked for a CCM opinion regarding the ACELC, or even of the fact that an opinion had been given. It was only many months after the opinion was rendered that someone happened across it and made the ACELC Board of Directors aware of its existence.

There have been many voices in the LCMS that have called for the CCM to be revamped or even abolished. We do not wish to enter into those discussions at this time. We would, however, like to set the record straight. Since CCM Opinion 11-2589 simply does not apply to the ACELC, we must respectfully but wholeheartedly reject it. You may find CCM opinion 11-2589 (on page #170) and the ACELC response by clicking on these links.

If you have any questions regarding this CCM opinion or the ACELC response, please do not hesitate to ask. We would also like to take this opportunity to ask you to visit our website and examine our many documents and papers. From the beginning, we in the ACELC have worked hard to do everything in a very open and transparent manner. We sincerely desire your feedback and ask for your prayerful consideration and support. We also pray for God’s continued blessings upon the LCMS that we would one day be truly united in Christ, and that our unity would be truly expressed in word and deed.

In Christ,

Rev. Clint K. Poppe
Chairman, ACELC

P.S. While we have your attention we would also like to take this opportunity to announce the Fourth Annual ACELC “Free Conference” and Business Meeting, which is scheduled for February 25-27, 2014, at Our Redeemer Lutheran Church in Cedar Falls, Iowa. The topic will be announced shortly, but we wanted you to be able to mark the date  on your calendar now.

About Norm Fisher

Norm was raised in the UCC in Connecticut, and like many fell away from the church after high school. With this background he saw it primarily as a service organization. On the miracle of his first child he came back to the church. On moving to Texas a few years later he found a home in Lutheranism when he was invited to a confessional church a half-hour away by our new neighbors.

He is one of those people who found a like mind in computers while in Middle School and has been programming ever since. He's responsible for many websites, including the Book of Concord,, and several other sites.

He has served the church in various positions, including financial secretary, sunday school teacher, elder, PTF board member, and choir member.

More of his work can be found at


ACELC — CCM’s Hidden Opinions — 4 Comments

  1. Indeed history can and does repeat itself. Amazing to see how those who address problems in the church are often the ones singled out as the problem. This happened to Spurgeon during the Down-Grade Controversy, it is happening in the Nazarene denomination, and it’s happening even here.

  2. Five months before a pastor submitted questions to the CCM on April 4, 2011, there was a meeting between ACELC representatives and synodical officials, which produced an ACELC News Release – 11/12/2010 – Report Of 2nd Meeting With COP Representatives.

    Perhaps these synodical officials who met with the ACELC were able provide encouragement to the CCM to eventually issue a four-issue opinion that was (in the ACELC’s words) “not applicable to the ACELC” for all four issues.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.