District Presidents Who Tilt at Windmills

Straw manIs this quote…

…As traditional Christians are driven from the [public] square, the door is also closed for the Gospel.

…synonymous with this quote?:

…The church, besieged by spiritual and temporal forces, must withdraw from the field, raise the drawbridge and fortify our church walls in order to protect what we hold dear.

The first quote was originally made by Synod President Matt Harrison in the April 2013 issue of The Lutheran Witness, and now quoted out of context by California-Nevada-Hawaii District President Robert Newton in a campaign letter sent to the convention delegates in his District. The second quote is a portion of President Newton’s summary of President Harrison’s position and theology. He was campaigning for “his guy,” District President David Maier, and his talking points sound eerily similar to the talking points used by another District President.  President Harrison’s comment reflects his determination to continue to do battle on the field: “The task before us is monumental.  …We are called to confess Christ to all.  …Let’s go!”  These are fighting words.  They aren’t the words of someone who is raising the drawbridge.

I don’t know President Maier, but judging from President Harrison’s description of him, he sounds like a great guy:

I know Herb Mueller and David Maier well. Herb is truly “an Israelite in whom there is no guile.” David loves the Scriptures and applying them to real people in real life. They, at the will of the congregations of Synod, are standing for election because they believe deeply in the Gospel, and they live to serve for the sake of Jesus and His message of salvation. They want the very best for the Synod. They are fine men who would bring many gifts to the office. They and their dear wives and families deserve our thanks.

I wonder what President Maier thinks of District Presidents who knock down self-stuffed straw men so that “their guy” will be elected?

You can read President Newton’s letter here.


photo credit:  peter pearson on flikr

About Scott Diekmann

Scott is a lifelong LCMS layman. Some of his vocations include husband, dad, jet driver, runner, and collector of more books than he can read. Oh, and also chocolate lover. He’s been involved in apologetics for over a decade, is on the Board of Regents at Concordia Portland, and is a column writer for the sometimes operational Around the Word Journal. He’s also written for Higher Things Magazine, The Lutheran Clarion, and has been a guest on Issues Etc. as well as the KFUO program Concord Matters.


District Presidents Who Tilt at Windmills — 9 Comments

  1. Bob Newton is right about one thing. By his own admission “… President Harrison and his administration have chosen to lead Synod down a road quite different from the one CNH is traveling.” That’s why the CNH congregation I’ve served for nearly thirty years has been walking down a road quite different from the one the CNH, under the leadership of DP Newton, is traveling. But we haven’t felt alone. There are others out here with whom we have long walked together… and we thank God for them.

  2. Newton is ignoring the key piece of context, namely that Harrison made those comments in HHS debate, describing how the Barack Obama-secularist want to say any religion that has presumptions about human nature isn’t a valid argument in the public square. Doesn’t Newton notice how people in his home state are vilified by the Hollywood elite if they voted for or donated to Prop 8?

  3. Pr. Matt Harrison is a gentleman of the highest degree, a solid leader, and a man with conviction. I admire his steadfast spirit in allowing the Holy Spirit to lead this election. These DPs should be removed from office for their self-serving underhanded remarks.

    I will continue to pray for the Synod, Districts, Circuits, and congregations that the delegates will submit to God’s Will….and not look at the personality and breeding of the candidates, but instead turn to Holy Scripture as their source of guidance to discern the fruits of these men. I pray the man that is picked will be picked for his willingness to submit to Scripture, abide by our Confessions, and remain steadfast in fostering a Christ-Centered ministry.

    Soli Deo Gloria!

  4. Pax Christ – All!

    I hate to say this, wishing my Synod were “synod” and not disparate elements walking around apart, but that is the case . . .

    Matters under Bohlmann were better than the present situation. I believe Harrison will win handily, but not without exposing the wide rift in our midst that truly exists. We are watching it unfold the closer we get to Convention. I do not expect many positives coming out of Convention. I pray I am wrong . . . I really don’t look forward to Convention, either. Gotta go, though.

    Mac – I agree. Harrison is indeed a gentleman of the highest order, and an excellent theologian – precisely what we need at the helm. I have no desire to minimize those DP’s who are coming to the forefront in opposition, nor do I wish to accuse them of a thing – except – I wish they would quit accusing their own selves.

    I am not at all sure when the Gospel in Word and Sacrament became somehow insufficient as a “mission tool.” It did not and cannot, but it seems some think it has.

    The Lord will guide the Church anyway. He always has. Those opposed, subtlety or not, stand opposed.

    The foxholes inch ever closer.

  5. What does DP Maier say about all this? How does he view the political machinations of his fellow DP’s? I would hope that he would speak out against such blatant politicking.

  6. > I would hope that he would speak out against such blatant politicking.

    He had to agree to being on the ballot didn’t he? No way will any candidate promoted by leftists ever speak against his backers.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.