The Best Construction — Luther on the 8th commandment

Theological discussion centered in the article of Justification is one of the many treasures that Jesus Christ gives to His Bride, the Church, (Matthew 18:19-20).  Wherever and whenever two or three are gathered in the Name of Jesus, Christ Himself is present.  This is first and foremost understood in the context of worship where the assembly of all believers is gathered in the means of grace. In addition to this, we carry this consolation of the brethren in our theological dialogue.

In keeping with the commands of our Lord Christ that His Bride join together in fellowship, we must always put the best construction on our discussions. Luther defines the 8th commandment saying, “You shall not give false testimony against your neighbor. What does this mean? We should fear and love God so that we do not tell lies about our neighbor, betray him, slander him, or hurt his reputation, but defend him, speak well of him, and explain everything in the kindest way” (Small Catechism).

The pivotal point in Luther’s definition is in the last part, “explain everything in the kindest way,” or better understood, “put the best construction on everything.” If we approach theological discussion with the worst intentions, or with the hope that our fellow believer is a heretic, then that will be the outcome. Fruitful dialogue will not happen if it begins with assumptions and hesitations. If we listen to gossip and the lies spread about our neighbor, then we will approach them with the intention, not of improving their life, but of revealing their sinful condition in pharisaic pride.

I mention these things as a parish Pastor. Gossip and slander are poison for any congregation or church body. The moment a reputation is ruined, it is ruined forever. Forgiveness of sins doesn’t eliminate a bad reputation from the minds of the assembly. There is only one solution to this problem and it is the preaching of God’s commandments.

Luther clarified the 8th commandment and its destruction of gossip saying, “To avoid this vice, therefore, we should note that none has the right to judge and reprove a neighbor publicly, even after having seen a sin committed, unless authorized to judge and reprove. There is a very great difference between judging sin and having knowledge of sin. You may certainly know about a sin, but you should not judge it. I may certainly see and hear that my neighbor sins, but I have no command to tell others about it. If I were to interfere and pass judgment in him, I would fall into a sin greater than that of my neighbor. When you become aware of a sin, however, do nothing but turn your ears into a tomb and bury it until you are appointed a judge and are authorized to administer punishment by virtue of your office” ( Large Catechism 8th commandment paragraphs 265-266).

Luther states that  our ears should become like tombs for gossip about our neighbor until we are in a God appointed position of judgment. But why? Why must we remain silent in the face of sin? What is the point? Shouldn’t we protect the weaker brother in the case of open sin? Luther answers the question as to the private nature of the 8th commandment saying, “Let this be your rule, then, that you should not be quick to spread slander and gossip about your neighbors but admonish them privately so that they may improve. Likewise, do the same when others tell you what this or that person has done. Instruct them, if they saw the wrongdoing, to go and reprove the individual personally or otherwise to hold their tongue” (Ibid 276).

The negative aspect of the 8th commandment is to not slander your neighbor or hurt his reputation. This negative is preached in order that the positive nature of the commandment may be carried out in the Christian life. The purpose of this commandment is to silence our poisonous tongues in order that we do nothing except defend our neighbor and seek his improvement. Luther concludes his thoughts on the 8th commandment saying, “Thus in our relations with one another all of us should veil whatever is dishonorable and weak in our neighbors, and do whatever we can to serve, assist, and promote their good name. On the other hand, we should prevent everything that may contribute to their disgrace, It is a particularly fine, noble virtue to put the best construction on all we may hear about our neighbors (as long as it is not an evil that is publicly known), and to defend them against the poisonous tongues of those who are busily trying to pry out and pounce on something to criticize in their neighbor, misconstruing and twisting things in the worst way” (Ibid 288-289).

The last paragraph in the Large Catechism is a great warning from Luther that says, “There is nothing around or in us that can do greater good or greater harm in temporal or spiritual matters than the tongue, although it is the smallest and weakest member.” The tongue kills and makes alive in the proclamation of the law and the gospel. Only in the proper distinction and sound application of the two is a believer created and sustained. Only in the best construction does the pastor and the layman approach the brethren with the purpose of improving the believer in order that they may overcome sin and win the victory through faith in Jesus Christ.

Let us heed these warnings from Luther concerning how we deal with our neighbor. Luther does not say that we should compromise or ignore sin, but that we should live with our brothers and sisters by veiling them in the blood of Christ. Let us always seek our improvement in our Christian life, but also let us humbly approach our fellow believers in Christ in order that they may be improved, not provoked to wickedness and further gossip. Fellowship exists only in the forgiveness of sins, purchased for us by Christ on the cross and delivered to us in the means of grace. Let us cling to Christ and silence the devil’s lies. Let us seek one another’s forgiveness and therefore walk together in the grace of our Lord, Jesus Christ.

About Pastor Chris Hull

Chris Hull is the Senior Pastor of Zion Evangelical Lutheran Church in Tomball,Texas. He was married to Allison Desiree Monk on June 3rd, 2006. They have been blessed with four boys, Lochlann Richard Patrick, Eamonn Julius Luther, Tiernann Thomas Walther, and Jamesonn Frederick Flacius. Pastor Hull graduated from Concordia University in River Forest, Il in 2006. He received his Master of Divinity from Concordia Theological Seminary, Fort Wayne, Indiana, 2010. He is currently in the STM program at CTSFW.


The Best Construction — Luther on the 8th commandment — 10 Comments

  1. A man who lacks judgment derides his neighbor,
    but a man of understanding holds his tongue.
    Whoever goes about slandering reveals secrets,
    but he who is trustworthy in spirit keeps a thing covered.
    Proverbs 11:12-13 ESV

    A gossip betrays a confidence; so avoid a man who talks too much.
    Proverbs 20:19 ESV

    For lack of wood the fire goes out,
    and where there is no whisperer, quarreling ceases.
    Proverbs 26:20 ESV

    Let no corrupting talk come out of your mouths, but only such as is good for building up, as fits the occasion, that it may give grace to those who hear. Ephesians 4:29 ESV

  2. Isn’t the quote of Jesus more properly understood in and through conflict? Seems to me from reading the text it’s not much about worship, and to say its primarily regarding worship is a stretch.

  3. @TK #3
    Thank you for the insight. Our fellowship as believers is created and sustained in the proclamation of the Gospel and the distribution of the sacraments. We are one in Christ in Baptism and are one fellowship as we eat the same bread and drink from the same cup. Christ is present and His Name is called upon foremost and primarily in Worship. The Divine Service is the place where Jesus is present, serving us in the forgiveness of sin. Because we are united in Christ through the common fellowship of forgiveness, we now gather together as the consolation of the brethren and call upon the Name of Jesus in any time of conflict. I don’t think we should pin the two against one another, rather we should see our daily fellowship flowing from our fellowship created in the Divine Service.

  4. Ok, but don’t you need to let the Biblical Text speak rather than impress the worship piece on it? Worship, let alone formal worship isn’t mentioned in Matt 18. Your hermeneutics seem to run through an understanding of worship.

  5. @TK #5
    TK. You are correct. Scripture interprets Scripture. We let the bible interpret itself. Jesus is present where His disciples are gathered in His Name. In Matthew 28 Christ sends out the Apostles to Baptize and to teach and through these Christ is with His Church always, to the End of the Ages. Christ is Bodily present in the Lord’s Supper under the forms of bread and wine. Jesus is not an abstraction. He is a physically risen Lord who is present with us physically in the means of grace for the forgiveness of our sins. This is not a liturgical hermeneutic, but an assertion of what Holy Scripture says about Jesus Christ. The text of Matthew 18 is not about conflict resolution, but about how Christians are commanded by Christ to forgive one another’s sin. We don’t understand the bible through Worship, rather our worship is defined by Holy Scripture. Thank you and I hope that this clarifies any misunderstanding.

  6. Does the Large Catechism have anything to say about putting the best construction on the motives or behavior of neighbors?

  7. lying for = santa claus
    lying against = sin
    true for = reputation = speak when can …
    true against = judgement is playing god

  8. I know this is an old post, but does this “putting the best construction on everything” include politics and politicians? It seems to me that if we all really sought to put the best construction on each politician, and everything that did or said, we would end up with a very false picture of reality, and i fail to see how that would be good.

    Also, is it “gossip” to discuss political news, and to be a little sarcastic towards the politicians we dislike? (i.e.”Bernie is advicating legalized theft again.”)?

  9. Joe, I wondered that myself in another context. If I know without a doubt, by my own experience, that a financial planner is dishonest and lies and cheats clients, and someone asks me about that planner, should I then “put the best construction on everything” and say that they are great and trustworthy? Wouldn’t I then actually be breaking the actual commandment to not bear false witness?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.